Core 139, Fall, 2023
Syllabus

The contains details about the topics of this course and the organization of the course, including grading. The course will be organized as two independent but related modules: Module A will focus on voting technologies and the use of computers to influence elections. Module B will focus on election methods such as plurality, run-off, and ranked-choice methods.

This syllabus presents the weekly topics and assignments. The details of the syllabus and adjustments will be filled in as the course proceeds.

Grading is explained in the course description.

The assignments are due on the day they are listed and the quizzes should be done online on Moodle by the end of the day that they are listed..

The readings refer by author to the following books:

Readings:                                                                                                         
A Brief Illustrated History of Voting, Douglas W. Jones (online)                     
Chaotic Elections, Donald Saari

Other readings will be given as links to web pages.
Quizzes are on Moodle.

Recommended Readings: The History and Politics of Voting, Roy G. Saltman; Election Meltdown, Richard Hasen

There will have weekly discussion papers on the topic for each week, based on the reading for that week.
Each paper should be about two pages. These will be due 6 pm Sunday evening before the classes for those readings, by email to the instructor.

Class meets Tu-Th, 9:55-11:10 in 315 McGregory

Office: 319B (off the student research lounge at west end) Office hours : Mon 10:30- 12:30, Tuesday 1:00-2:00, Weds 10:30-11:00

Course Schedule

date                topic                                   reading                                       assignment/quiz


Aug     24        Get syllabus and first assignment: discussion paper 1. Also look at discussion paper 5          
Friday 25        Library instruction at Case/Geyer 345 (east side of main floor) with Peter Tagtmeyer
                        resources: https://libguides.colgate.edu/CORE139  (also under discussion paper 5 below)


Sun    27        Discussion paper week 1  Due
          29        History of Voting        A Brief Illustrated History of Voting
         
31        Florida 2000


Sept   3         Discussion paper week 2   Due
          5         Voting Equipment            Verified Voting   (Look under Resources and VerifierVoting Technology, MIT Labs
          7         Auditing Elections          National Council of State Legislators         H.R.1


        10      Discussion paper week 3   Due
        12      Helios voting experience                    Benaloah Talk 
                  Scantegrity
        14      Scantegrity and other End-to-End (E2E) voter verifiable methods


       17    Discussion paper week 4 - Lab 1   Due   
       19      Gerrymandering lab: play the gerrymander game before class. Discussion. 
                 What role can computers play?  Redistricting methods using computer programs
       21      Discussion of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court decisions on Gerrymandering
                  Supreme court Gerrymandering decision-1 decison-2   MD-map NC-map
                  PennsylvaniaRedistrictDecision   Reasons for PA decision

                  Harvard Law Review on Redistricting in HR 1


       24      Discussion paper week 5   Due    Paper topics due -- One paragraph paper proposal
       26      Voter fraud cases
       28     Are stringent voter ID laws appropriate? Is mail-in Voting OK? Did Trump really win?



Oct   3      Debate prep - meet with each team    debate topics  debate teams
         5       Debate: A government issued photo ID should be required to vote


       9/10      Fall Break
       12       Debate:   Convicted Felons should recover their right to vote after serving their sentence (including probabtion)    
       13      Mid-term papers due      



       17      Debate: There should be a Federal law requiring states to use risk-limiting audits for all Federal elections
       17      Discussion paper B1 due
       19      Nassau County problem -- weighted voting Nassau solution example      



       22      Discussion paper B2 due
       24      Banzhaf Index of Power applied to N.C solutions    Banzhaf-1
                Banzhaf analysis of Electoral College
       26     Discussion of the electoral college. What are alternatives?
                  National Popular Vote Interstate Compact


      29       Discussion paper B3 due
      31       Discussion of different ways to make choices -- elections
                     Formal definition of an election method.
Nov  2      Third candidates, Saari pp 17- 27
                  Voting methods overview                            example profile
                  Classification of Voting Methods
         

         5     No discussion paper
         7     What makes a good election method? Arrow's theorem Saari pp 27-31
         9     Analysis of voting methods Saari pp 33-45      ProcedureRules   GeometricRepresentation  
       10      Quiz 1 on on voting methods due (on Moodle)         

      12      No discussion paper due.  Read Saari, 33-45
      14      Analysis of voting methods     Saari pp 45-68     Other methods   ProfileAndAnalysis   FourCandidateProfile  
     16       Lab 2: creating a voting profile
     17      Quiz 2 on Arrow's Thoerem due (on Moodle)

    18-26 Thanksgiving break



      26       No discussion paper -- read over lab 2
      28       No Class        
      30       Chaotic results Saari, ch 3
Dec  1        No Quiz


        3      Discussion paper B4 due
        5      Strategic voting Saari, ch. 4, Sections 1-4  Agendas     FourCandidateExample
        7      What voters want? Saari, ch. 5   Review  Canceling Ties
        8      Quiz 3 on strategic voting and solutions (Saari, ch 4 and 5)
                Takehome part of final due on Moodle


Final Exam:  Monday, Dec 11, 9:00-11:00


 

--

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Office hours : email for a zoom session. Mon 10:30- 12:30, Wednesday 12:30-1:30, Thursday on request. Email to request a zoom session.